Breaking News
More () »

Mixed Fillings Pie Shop perfect way to celebrate Pi Day

On a day based on the infinite number Pi, there are seemingly infinite options to choose from at Mixed Fillings.

JACKSONVILLE, Fla. — It's a day when mathematicians and dessert lovers can all come together: Pi Day, or 3/14, dedicated to the infinite mathematical constant calculated as the ratio of a circle's circumference to its diameter.

While Pi's neverending decimals are approximately equal to 3.14159, the day celebrated in its honor is the truncated version -- 3/14, or March 14. And because memorizing digits is not as fun as gorging oneself on round baked goods, most people choose to celebrate Pi Day with a homophone of Pi, pie.

And what better place to scarf down some pie than Jacksonville's very own Mixed Fillings Pie Shop?

The bakery, located on a street corner in Avondale inside a rectangular building, serves triangular slices of all its round pies, and Pi Day is one of its busiest times of the year. Owner Natasha Burton says they offer a seemingly endless assortment.

"We specialize in sweet and savory pies, so we've got custard pies, fruit pies, chicken pot pie, pecan pie, coconut cream pie," Burton said. "Basically, if it's an ingredient that you can put into pie form, we're turning it into a pie."

With seemingly infinite options, a day based on an infinite number like Pi is quite hectic for a business that makes pie.

"Pi Day is the busiest day of the year for us," Burton said. "It is complete insanity. After Pi Day, I will be sleeping for 24 hours."

Burton, originally from Dallas, wanted to help children learn how to create gardens when she first went to culinary school. But, through creating community, she discovered her love of baking. 

After fewer than three years in business, Mixed Fillings Pie Shop is expanding to a new and larger location.

"I never could have imagined that coming to Jacksonville would have propelled our business as quickly and as largely as it has," Burton said. "It's been a dream come true."

Mixed Fillings earned the accolade of the Best Place for Pie in the entire U.S. according to a Yelp survey. The user review-based site compiled lists of the best places for pie in every state, and Mixed Fillings was No. 1 in Florida and nationwide.

Another Jacksonville dessert shop, Amaretti Desserts, took the No. 12 spot on the Florida list.

The rest of the list of the best places for pie in Florida are as follows, according to Yelp:

  1. Mixed Fillings Pie Shop – Jacksonville
  2. Sweet Delights Key Lime Pies – Florida City
  3. Pie Heaven Bakery Cafe – Atlantic Beach
  4. Floribbean Flo's Tropical Bakery – Sarasota
  5. Blond Giraffe Key Lime Pie Factory – Tavernier
  6. Fireman Derek's Bake Shop & Cafe – Miami
  7. Desserts by Toffee to Go – Tampa
  8. Knaus Berry Farm – Homestead
  9. Sister Honey's – Orlando
  10. P is for Pie Bake Shop – Orlando
  11. Se7en Bites – Orlando
  12. Amaretti Desserts – Jacksonville
  13. Sweet Savannah's – Marathon
  14. Fookem's Fabulous Key Lime Pie – Coconut Grove
  15. The Proper Pie Company – Davenport
  16. Craft Kafe – Saint Petersburg
  17. Midway Cafe and Coffee Bar – Islamorada
  18. Joan's Perfect Pie – Melbourne
  19. dbakers Sweet Studio – Miami
  20. Donut Hole Bakery Cafe – Destin

RELATED: Pandemic Pivot: Woman goes from being jobless to selling out pies at her own shop in Jacksonville

RELATED: Mixed Fillings Pie Shop celebrates community members doing good deeds (FCL September 15th 2020)