Breaking News
More () »

Jacksonville's Leading Local News: Weather, Traffic, Sports and more | Jacksonville, Florida | FirstCoastNews.com

'Monster of Mayport' reportedly continues killing two decades after notorious mass murder

He told First Coast News he'd kill again. Now, according to law enforcement sources, he did -- two weeks ago, at Florida State Prison.

JACKSONVILLE, Fla. — In May 2003, William Wells killed five people, starting with his wife.

He hid their decomposing bodies inside his double-wide trailer on Ocean Street in Mayport where he continued to live with his 4-year-old son for more than a week.

The crime earned him five consecutive life sentences.

He drew a sixth life sentence when he attempted to kill an inmate at Miami-Dade Correctional Institution in 2008. He got a seventh life sentence for murdering a fellow inmate at Florida State Prison in 2011.

Now, the self-described “Monster” of Mayport has allegedly killed again.

READ MORE >> From 2011: William Wells, the Monster of Mayport, currently serving six life sentences, also facing another first-degree murder charge

'It was like something you see in a horror movie'

Law enforcement and prison sources confirm that Wells and a second inmate strangled and brutally stabbed 32-year-old William Chapman to death inside Florida State Prison on July 5 of this year. Chapman was serving time for burglaries committed in Volusia County. Wells has not yet been charged.

A state employee who saw a video of the attack says it was brutal.

“The two subjects had [Chapman] up against the door, stabbing him,” a state employee who saw a video of the attack tells First Coast News. “The officers couldn’t gain access to the room. Wells was strangling him. They were constantly stabbing him, stabbing him, stabbing him.”

“That video was so gruesome,” he adds. “It was like something you see in a horror movie.”

First Coast News was unable to reach Chapman’s family for comment.

Wells’ alleged accomplice, Leo Boatman, was previously convicted of murdering two Santa Fe College students with an AK-47 while they were camping in the Ocala National Forest in 2006. He was subsequently convicted of beating a cellmate to death in 2011.

Credit: Leo Boatman, Wells' alleged accomplice

'My quest for lethal injection continues...'

Wells’ has communicated over the years with First Coast News, beginning with a telephone confession in 2003, saying his crime spree began with the accidental killing of his wife, Irene Wells. He says the couple was joking around with what he thought was an unloaded gun.

LISTEN: Hear the 2003 phone interview where William Wells confesses to the 2003 killing spree (five-part series)

"And she goes, 'now what are you going to do?,'" Wells said in the 2003 telephone interview. "And I stuck it to the back of her head and I said, 'this,' and I pulled the trigger and it went off. … I literally, literally defecated my pants. I watched her face spray against the wall in front of me and she fell over."

Wells said at the time he wanted to plead guilty and face the death penalty but instead received five life sentences.

He reached out to First Coast News again in a 2011 letter, appearing to revel in beating the criminal justice system but suggesting he still wanted the death penalty.

"Contrary to the elements of your justice system, I managed to prevail with a mere five life sentences," he wrote. 

He noted that if prosecutors were "more thorough in convicting me in 2003 of the Mayport murders and pushing fervently for the death penalty, no one else would have had to die."

“I guess my quest for the lethal injection continues, and more time goes by," he added.

Credit: William "Billy" Wells

Then-State Attorney Harry Shorstein has defended the decision not to pursue death, citing the wishes of the victims’ families and Wells’ questionable sanity.  

"It's a case that looking at the facts warrants seeking the death penalty,” he told First Coast News in 2011. “But when you give consideration to the other factors, the legal factors, as well as the wishes of the family, and the offer to plead guilty and to have the case disposed of very, very quickly.”

We reached out to Shorstein for comment on the recent incident, as well as current State Attorney Melissa Nelson, who prosecuted the Wells case. Nelson’s role became an issue in her 2016 election when then-incumbent State Attorney Angela Corey criticized her for not seeking the death penalty. Nelson dismissed the criticism, noting Corey was her supervisor at the time.

Wells’ most recent letter to First Coast News, in August 2018, complains about conditions at Florida State Prison as corrupt and inhumane. He notes in a postscript, “You may remember me form the Mayport Mass Murder case of 2003.”

In the letter, Wells complains about conditions at Florida State Prison as corrupt and inhumane. He notes in a postscript, "You may remember me form the Mayport Mass Murder case of 2003."

Asked about Chapman’s death, the Florida Department of Corrections confirms “active homicide investigation” by the Florida Department of Law Enforcement but declined to provide details. 

Their statement notes, “The safe and secure operation of Florida’s correctional institutions is the Department of Corrections’ top priority. Every inmate death is thoroughly investigated by law enforcement and the Department’s Office of Inspector General to ensure independent oversight and absolute accountability at all levels.”