As Spain sinks, many in Catalonia want out

2:14 PM, Sep 27, 2012   |    comments
Getty Images
  • Share
  • Email
  • Print
  • - A A A +

BARCELONA, Spain -- This historic region on the Mediterranean -- a center of European industrial design and tourism -- has special status as an autonomous district of Spain known as Catalonia.

And as financial problems mount for Spain, many here want to get a whole lot more autonomous.

The Spanish government on Thursday announced another round of austerity measures aimed at building confidence that deficit reduction targets can be met. With Spain entering its second recession in four years, some Catalans say they are getting little for the river of tax revenue they send to Madrid annually and are pushing for outright independence.

While secession may sound like an unlikely event, Spain is taking it seriously given the country's heavy reliance on this economic powerhouse.

"Financially speaking, Catalonia is perfect for Spain," said Osvald Calzada, 32, a copywriter from Lleida, in the western part of the region. "Catalonia is the cow they constantly milk, only giving her enough grass to survive."

King Juan Carlos has called for national unity as the governor of Catalonia announced Tuesday that elections will be held in November, two years ahead of schedule in what is widely seen as a referendum on the region's independence.

The louder demands for independence in Catalonia are the latest divisive consequence of the European debt crisis, analysts say. As budget deficits grow, officials have had to slash funds for education, health services and public sector workers. More austerity measures were announced Thursday.

Catalonia, which encompasses four provinces, has not escaped the curtailment of public services and jobs. But many here say it is unfair given that 7.5 million Catalans pay $15 billion to $20 billion more in taxes annually than they get back from Madrid in social services or infrastructure.

Despite its economic vitality, Catalonia is currently Spain's most indebted region. Recently the government here asked Madrid for $6.2 billion in financial assistance, but not in a loan. The government wanted the money free and clear, saying it belongs to them and was wasted by the Spanish government.

Rebuffed by Madrid, Catalan officials last week entered into negotiations with Madrid to push for greater financial independence from Spain. The talks went nowhere.

"There is no other territory in the world suffering such fiscal plundering," said Marc Guerrero, professor of international finance at European University in Barcelona. "If we could collect and keep all taxes, this wouldn't have happened and the standard of living of Catalans would be much higher."

Anger was on display for all to see on Sept. 11, Catalonia's National Day, when an estimated 1.5 million people filled the streets bearing signs that said, "Catalonia, the next independent state in Europe," and "We want a divorce because we are not happy in this marriage."

People sang the Catalan national anthem and marched through the city in one of the largest demonstrations in the history of Spain and aimed at Madrid. A recent media poll showed that 51% of Catalans would vote in favor of separating from Spain, the highest percentage ever marked on a survey.

Analysts say that the younger generation doesn't feel the ghost of Spain's former military dictatorship of Francisco Franco â?? when any form of separatism was persecuted â?? and have been taught in school about the oppression suffered under the Spaniards for more than three centuries of Catalonia's 1,000 years of existence.

An unemployment rate in the region of almost 22% is also fueling rhetoric from pro-independence parties.

In its latest response to the debt crisis, Spain approved a budget Thursday that froze public sector wages for the third year in a row, cut government spending by 12% and imposed a new 20% tax on winnings from lotteries above $3,230. Spain was also expected to raise the retirement age from 65 to 67.

Spain, which has the third-largest economy in the 17-member euro zone (the countries that use the euro as currency), was requited to make such cutsto qualify for financial assistance from other European nations.

Analysts have said that Spain needs at least $77 billion for its shaky banks to be stabilized to make up for an estimated $383 billion in toxic loans and capital flight. An audit of the banking system is taking place Friday to determine the extent of the banking system's troubles.

On Thursday, Spanish region Castilla-La Mancha became the fifth region to ask Madrid for a bailout in the amount of $1 billion.

Talk of Catalonia independence in this financial climate prompted Spain's royal family to speak up, a rare move. The king, the head of state, has diplomatic duties and traditionally stays out of politics.

"In these circumstances, the worst thing we can do is divide our forces, encourage dissent, chase chimeras and deepen wounds," King Juan Carlos said.

The last time the king spoke publicly on politics was in regard to a coup attempt in 1981, three years after democracy had been re-established in the post-Franco period.

The king knows there is much at stake: If Catalonia were to leave, Spain would lose an economic engine that contributes 20% of its economy and holds one of the most important commercial harbors in the Mediterranean.

Mikel Buesa, an economics professor at Madrid's Complutense University, thinks both Catalonia and Spain would suffer with the split.

"Surrounding Catalonia with borders would bring its GDP down by 30%, Spaniards would boycott Catalan products (like in 2006), and many companies would leave the territory, possibly to settle in Spain," Buesa said.

Others disagree.

"Catalonia doesn't need Spain," Guerrero said. "Last year we already exported more to foreign countries than to Spain, and Catalonia alone exported 25% of the total Spanish exports."

The European Union has already warned Catalans that if they leave Spain they will have to seek readmission to the bloc, a process that, according to Buesa, could take years with all EU members unanimously required to approve the candidacy â?? including Spain.

That has left the leader of Catalonia, Artur Mas, in a tricky position. While seeing his region leave Spain is not his top choice, the Spanish government is refusing to negotiate while pro-independence sentiment at home rises.

"With all its refusals, Spain is showing us the way out the door," Calzada said. "It won't be easy, but I am convinced that we will stay afloat, just like we always have."

USA Today