TAM DAO, Vietnam -- Bears, some of them blinded or maimed, play
behind tall green fences like children at school recess. Rescued from
Asia's bear bile trade, they were brought to live in this lush national
park, but now they may need saving once more.
The future of the
bears' sanctuary has been in doubt since July, when a vice defense
minister ordered the nonprofit group operating the $2 million center not
to expand further and to find another location. U.S. politicians and
officials in other countries are among those urging the military to back
off.
The defense official wrote, without elaborating, that the
Chat Dau Valley is of strategic military interest, but environmentalists
allege that vested interests have urged an eviction. They point to
documents showing that the daughter of the park's director is involved
in a proposed ecotourism venture that wants to lease park land.
Conservation
groups say the dispute in Tam Dao National Park is emblematic of
conflicts brewing across Vietnam's protected areas. When developers want
the land, they say, environmental safeguards disappear.
Vietnamese
laws adhere to international environmental standards, but in practice
are "minor considerations" in land-use and infrastructure-planning
decisions, the World Bank said in a report last year.
Vietnam is
among the most biologically diverse countries on earth, comprising less
than 1 percent of the world's land but about 10 percent of its species.
But the report noted that its protected areas are suffering from
deforestation and habitat loss.
"It doesn't matter if the forests
are protected by law or not," said Trinh Le Nguyen, executive director
of People and Nature Reconciliation, one of Vietnam's few locally based
conservation groups. If officials and community groups are not vocal
enough, "then the private sector will try (to get) wealthier and
wealthier."
Conservationists cite the example of northern Ba Be
National Park, where pollution from ore mining is said to threaten a
freshwater lake that has received accolades from an international
environmental convention. Scientists and hundreds of residents have
protested that the pollution is causing the lake's water quality to
deteriorate, state media reported last year. A local Communist Party
official also has called for a probe into what the state-run Vietnam
News Agency calls "rampant deforestation" by loggers inside the park.
Elsewhere,
a proposal to develop two hydropower plants in Cat Tien National Park
in the south has triggered opposition because the dams would inundate
forests.
"It took generations to establish and maintain our
national parks," said former park director Tran Van Thanh, who is
calling for the proposal to be scrapped. "It would be a waste if we have
to surrender parts of our forests for economic development."
Vietnam
first established protected lands in the 1960s, and the network has
grown to include 30 national parks and scores of other protected areas
spanning forests and wetlands. But experts say local development agendas
often trump larger conservation goals as officials sell off protected
territory for mines, hydropower dams and infrastructure or real estate
projects.
Tensions between conservation and development have only
increased over the last decade in Vietnam. Land developers have become
wealthy, powerful and ambitious on the back of rapid economic growth.
Protected areas are typically under the control of local officials, who
receive little funding for conservation and view the areas as potential
sources of revenue.
"Vietnam is at a real crossroads where it has
to make some hard decisions about whether or not it values biodiversity
conservation," said Pamela McElwee, a professor of human ecology at
Rutgers University who conducts research in Vietnam's protected areas.
"The majority of folks working in the protected-area system are
genuinely dedicated ... but they're facing really powerful interests."
Vietnam's
poor enforcement of environmental laws is adding to international
criticism of its ruling Communist Party, which is castigated for its
human rights record and its handling of a sagging economy.
Ten
conservation groups, several foreign embassies and U.S. politicians have
written to Prime Minister Nguyen Tan Dung in recent weeks urging him to
not close the Vietnam Bear Rescue Centre, which lies 70 kilometers (43
miles) north of the capital, Hanoi.
They were alarmed by Vice
Defense Minister Do Ba Ty's July letter to the Ministry of Agriculture
and Rural Development. He directed the center not to expand further and
to find an alternate site in partnership with local officials. He wrote
that the Chat Dau Valley is of "strategic importance to national
defense."
"The expansion of the bear rescue center in this valley
will have direct impact on military projects," the letter said,
according to a copy given to the Associated Press by the sanctuary's
nonprofit operator, Hong Kong-based Animals Asia Foundation. The letter
did not explain why the land was of strategic importance.
Seven
Democratic U.S. representatives urged Dung to protect the sanctuary in a
Nov. 5 letter. "The claim that the land is an area of national defense
significance is questionable," they said, noting that the bear center
has operated since 2005 and the park has welcomed tourism since 1996.
The lead signer was Rep. Sam Farr of California.
Animals Asia says
an eviction would leave 104 rescued bears homeless and waste its $2
million investment, which was funded entirely by international
foundations, corporations and private donors. It says after an initial
trial period, the prime minister in 2008 approved its plan to build
facilities on about 11 hectares (27 acres) inside the roughly
39,000-hectare park, and that the center has so far expanded to half
those 11 hectares.
The group rescued bears that were being used to
produce bear bile, which has historically been used in China and other
Asian countries to treat fevers, pain, inflammation and other ailments.
Bears are typically captured in forests and transported to farms, where
the green bile is sucked from their gall bladders in a painful process
that sometimes kills them.
In recent weeks, Animals Asia has waged
a public relations campaign alleging park director Do Dinh Tien has a
personal stake in an ecotourism venture proposed for the park by the
Hanoi company Truong Giang Group.
Animals Asia's Vietnam director,
Tuan Bendixsen, said he believes the ecotourism project would be built
on the undeveloped half of the bear center's 11 hectares. Documents show
the company in March sent a team of surveyors to evaluate that parcel
and other park land for development.
"He wants to take half the
land, and he can't get it, and that's why he's creating all this trouble
for us," Bendixsen said of the park director.
In September 2011,
Do Dinh Tien asked the agriculture ministry to approve separate plans by
three companies, including Truong Giang, to develop ecotourism in Tam
Dao's national park, according to documents given to the AP.
Documents
show that days earlier, Truong Giang had asked Tien for permission to
lease 48 hectares of land in Tam Dao for an "ecological tourism and
entertainment project." Truong Giang's registration papers list Tien's
daughter, Do Thi Ngan, as one of its four shareholders.
Ngan and officials at the agriculture and defense ministries declined to comment.
In
an interview, Tien declined to discuss his daughter's relationship to
the company, saying he has not yet discussed the matter with her. But he
insisted he has never lobbied for the company's interests.
"From
my perspective, the bear center can go ahead if it follows procedures,"
Tien said recently at park headquarters. "But I can't speak for the
Ministry of Defense."
State media say the agriculture ministry is
working with the central government to resolve the dispute. The prime
minister has final say over the bear center's fate.
National
Assembly Deputy Duong Trung Quoc was quoted by online newspaper
Vietnamnet Wednesday as saying evicting the bear center could anger the
international community.
"It would do harm to our country's image," he said.
Associated Press