Kate the great? Style-wise, it's up for debate

USA Today

• FILED UNDER

At this point, Kate Middleton, aka Her Royal Highness the Duchess of Cambridge, has been photographed enough for style-watchers all over the world to have a pretty good grasp on her aesthetic and sense of style. But, has all that wedge-wearing and hair-tossing made her iconic? USA TODAY's Olivia Barker and Arienne Thompson go head-to-head to answer one simple question: Is Kate a style icon?

Arienne's take: Pretty girl with access to some great designers? Yes. Style icon? Not so much. She certainly helped breathe some new life into the royal family post-Diana, but unlike her oh-so-stylish late mother-in-law, the Duchess of Cambridge rarely excites when it comes to her sartorial choices.

Olivia's take: She may not stretch the seams of fashion like that other iconic British Kate, Ms. Moss. But Duchess Kate certainly sets a sterling standard for style .

Hair

Arienne: If there's one area where Kate knocks it out of the park nearly every time, it's her hair. Those cascading chestnut locks are always perfectly curled, and they have a healthy sheen that would make even Rapunzel jealous. But there's one pet peeve: She cannot keep her hands out of her hair!

Olivia: Could there be more captivating chestnut curls than Kate's? Blown out with just the right amount of bounce, the duchess' magnetic mane makes her a modern Breck girl. Wearing her locks long and loose, she keeps her look youthful.

Clothes

Arienne: Kate has the figure and height to pull off just about any look she likes, so it's a shame that, for the most part, she turns up in dresses that are flattering and pretty, but rarely very exciting. Imagine if she had Jennifer Lopez's look-at-me panache or even Angelina Jolie's smoldering glamour. How exciting the royal style watch would become! Instead, Kate, in all of her McQueen and Packham and Reiss glory, could be even prettier if she took more risks and had a little bit more fun with fashion. Sure, she looked perfectly fine in a girly oxblood Paule Ka skirt suit during an official appearance in London last week, but where's the excitement?

Olivia: They flutter. They flatter. They cinch right where they should - at Kate's enviably tiny waist. Details (subtle asymmetry, exposed zippers) add interest and edge. The above-the-knee hems give just enough of a gander at Kate's other asset: her shapely stems. The colors are pretty without being predictable. In a word, the duchess' wardrobe, including the Roksanda Ilincic Peridot dress in which she greeted Los Angeles, is stacked with gems. (And yes, she regularly recycles her frocks. But when she does, this ambassador of austerity smartly switches up her hair, accessories and shoes.)

Shoes

Arienne: By now, we all know exactly what shoes are lurking in the duchess' closet. From Stuart Weitzman wedges to simple LK Bennett platform pumps, she is the most staid in her choice of footwear. I look forward to the day when we get to see her in a marvelous stiletto or a trendy peeptoe bootie. At this point, I'll even take a studded flat! Anything to break up the monotony.

Olivia: Audrey is known for her ballet flats; Kate will be ever-connected to her similarly classic pumps. And in both instances, classic does not equal boring. Kate's almond toes are on-trend. The colors are chic, not corporate. The skinny stiletto heels tart them up ever so slightly (and appropriately).

Accessories

Arienne: It should come as no surprise that Kate is not a statement-necklace-and-designer-bag kind of girl. She sticks to simple jewelry that often complements her large sapphire engagement ring, and when we see her with any kind of purse, it's almost always a dainty evening clutch. She could certainly gain some style points with an interesting belt or a cool ring, or even a friendship bracelet or two like her bro-in-law Harry. Anything!

Olivia: When your engagement ring is one of the world's most famous baubles, there's no need to layer on competing sparkle. Kate wisely keeps the jewelry focus on her regal sapphire rock. And when it comes to her bags, yes, Kate typically stays in the neutral zone, but she often adds contrast in the form of texture.

Extras

Arienne: Kate's beauty regimen does little to enhance her natural beauty, as she relies too much on heavy eyeliner and mascara that detract from her pretty blue eyes. And then, there's the nude tights! Free your legs and invest in some quality self-tanner, Kate -- please!

Olivia: Here's perhaps an indefensible position: Kate's pantyhose are so invisible, so undetectable, that it almost doesn't matter if she's wearing them or not. For someone glad-handing all day, sheers serve a purpose. And guess what? Jackie wore them. So there.

USA Today