When a woman hides spending from her husband, she's likely to conceal
beauty purchases, such as cosmetics, an expensive purse, or a salon
visit.
When men sneak around with money, they commonly spend on entertainment, guns, power tools, even cars.
And more of us do it than you might think.
According
to a 2012 survey of 23,230 men and women by TODAY.com and SELF.com,
almost half of all married adults admit to keeping money secrets.
Lying
to a partner about money was admitted by 56% of women and 37% of men in
the poll. Thirty-two percent of women said they have hidden purchases
from their partner compared with 17% of men.
At the same time,
honesty about money is a value many married men and women say they prize
in relationships. Sixty-three percent of men and 70% of women said they
think honesty about money is as important as remaining monogamous.
While seemingly trivial, hiding expenses can damage relationships and be a sign of deeper problems.
"Financial
infidelity is marked by secrecy. Secrecy is a hallmark of the loss of
intimacy," said John K. Bell, a therapist and licensed clinical social
worker based in Louisville, Ky. "Financial infidelity can certainly
damage a relationship beyond repair ... just like sexual infidelity."
Women,
more than men, are likely to avoid conversations about money, said
author and financial pundit Suze Orman. Many women assume that attitude
because when it comes to money, "history favors the man, as handling the
money was always the man's domain," Orman said in her 2007 book, "Women
and Money."
"It is important that you have a totally open
relationship about every penny you have and you do not have. I am asking
you to settle for nothing less," she wrote. After bills are paid and
savings goals are met each month, Orman wrote, couples should divide
extra funds into two equal parts. The money can then be deposited in
separate checking accounts for each partner to spend as each wishes.
Overtime
at her nursing job helps Heather Lynn Kluemper, 40, stock a "secret
slush fund" for quarterly, $250 wrinkle injections, facials and peels at
the dermatologist. Kluemper said her husband, a banker, is unaware of
her Botox bank account.
"It's non-negotiable. It's mine. I like
that I can treat myself without having to ask permission," said
Kluemper, who relocated from Louisville to Lansing, Mich., in 2009 for
her husband's career. Her hidden "me fund" buoys her spirits amid the
duties of being a wife of 16 years, a full-time nurse to brain-injured
patients and mother of four boys, she said.
When Jackie Bay's
first marriage ended, money was a big battle. Her former spouse made
significant purchases just before he suddenly left the marriage in 2001,
she said. The breakup left her with a mortgage and new second mortgage
she could not afford.
Bay, 45, filed for bankruptcy protection as
a result, she said. Her ex-husband confirmed he still owns the
two-bedroom, one-bath cottage property but declined to comment further.
On
Dec. 10, Bay celebrated her first anniversary with a second husband, a
former construction worker who is a full-time student at ITT Technical
Institute, where Bay works as an administrative assistant. He works odd
jobs as a contractor.
Until he finds full-time employment upon
graduation in June as a computer network specialist, Bay is paying their
bills from her own bank account. If he uses her bank debit card for
household expenses, they review receipts together. The husband's
spending money comes from a joint account they both deposit funds into
as needed.
"He has no money and no possessions. All he cares about
is me. And we'll probably get along until he does start making money,"
Bay said.
Keeping track of joint accounts is easier than ever with
the advent of electronic banking, Louisville divorce lawyer A. Holland
Houston said. Engaged couples should even share credit scores, she
added. The hard part, she said, is being willing to have candid
conversations before tying the knot.
"If you are getting married
and don't trust each other, why are you getting married?" Holland said.
"People have to know what the other person is doing, because they could
end up paying for it someday."
What is your money personality?
"Very
few people feel neutral about money," said Louisville, Ky., therapist
John K. Bell. "We each have clear values about how we view money and a
couple must learn to be open and honest about those values and
feelings."
Couples can more easily talk about money if they identify common, and often unconscious, financial attitudes:
"Money
Avoidance" beliefs contend that money is bad and prompt some people to
shy away from reviewing bills or statements. People with this attitude
may have contempt for affluent people. These attitudes may sabotage
financial success and promote compulsive shopping.
"Money
Vigilance" behaviors include being "alert, watchful and concerned about
financial welfare." People with these beliefs eschew credit, pay cash,
are leery of risk and may withhold financial information from loved
ones.
People with "Money Status" attitudes "see net worth and
self-worth as being synonymous," believe "poor people are lazy," and
will buy only new items. Compulsive spending can be a problem as they
try to give the impression of wealth.
"Money Worship" attitudes include the belief that "money is power," and "if you have money, someone will take it away from you."
USA Today